Letter to the Sunday Herald regarding the Human Rights Act

In the first week of taking office, our newly elected government has prioritised an agenda to remove the keystone of human rights in this country and dismantle vital legal protections for each and every citizen. We, the undersigned, wish to express our opposition to the Government’s plans to extend the surveillance state, weaken Freedom of […]

May 15, 2015

In the first week of taking office, our newly elected government has prioritised an agenda to remove the keystone of human rights in this country and dismantle vital legal protections for each and every citizen. We, the undersigned, wish to express our opposition to the Government’s plans to extend the surveillance state, weaken Freedom of Information legislation and, above all, its declared intent to repeal the 1998 Human Rights Act.

We are deeply concerned at the implications for individuals and institutions, not least because the European Convention of Human Rights forms a fundamental part of the devolution settlements for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. Repealing the 1998 Act would, we believe, undermine key elements of constitutional relationships within the UK, and have ramifications for our place within the European Union. The Government has yet to publish any significant detail on its proposed ‘British Bill of Rights’ but we are alarmed by the ‘extremist’ language being used by ministers and their supporters in certain sections of the fourth estate. It is clear, however, that these plans represent a major transfer of power away from ordinary citizens and towards the state, corporations and large vested interests, including a diminution of the rights of individuals to sue governments.

Our free press enjoys many legal protections based on its historic function of holding governments and power to account. With these plans certain to place the basis of our civil rights under huge duress, we call on our free press to fulfil this essential, historic role as a defender of our freedoms.

All of our human rights have been under almost continuous assault since the turn of this century. Removal of the Human Rights Act will have many and unforeseen consequences but in the context of an already imminent increase in powers of surveillance and tightening anti-terrorist laws, the introduction of new legal definitions makes free speech more vulnerable than at any time since 1945. Scottish PEN will work with English PEN, Wales PEN Cymru and other PEN centres and human rights organisations across Europe to oppose the repeal of the Human Rights Act – including any consequent attempt by the British Government to withdraw from the European Convention of Human Rights.

As writers, we believe the right to free expression is fundamental to a healthy society and its relationship to the wider world. We will defend that right and all associated freedoms against attack from any vested interest or government body. We hope others will join us.

Signed:

Drew Campbell, President, Scottish PEN

Council of the Scottish Society of Playwrights

Caroline Adams

Jim Aitken

Andrew Anderson

Lin Anderson

Jane Archer

Neal Ascherson

Nick Barley

Martin Bates

Gillian Beattie-Smith

Alan Bissett

Rose Black

Ricky Brown

Maoilios Caimbeul

Jenni Calder

Karen Campbell

J Caplan

Aimee Chalmers

Martin Chick

Regi Claire

A C Clarke

Jo Clifford

Stewart Conn

Anne Connolly

Linda Cracknell

Ian Crockatt

Anna Crowe

Roy Dalgleish (Linlithgow Book Festival)

Claudia Daventry

Christine De Luca

Meaghan Delahunt

TM Devine

Colin Donati

Anne Donovan

Anne Dunford

Etta Dunn

Mary Edward

Nadine Edwards

Suzanne Egerton

Margaret Elphinstone

Vicki Feaver

Matthew Fitt

Una Leonie Flett

Moira Forsyth

Dr Peta Freestone

Iain Galbraith

Alan Gay

Kay Goodall

Mark O. Goodwin

Fiona Graham

Maggie Graham (Scottish Writers’ Centre)

Alasdair Gray

Stephanie Green

Diana Hendry

Brian Holton

Jules Horne

Tom Hubbard

Janet Ireland

Paula Jennings

Brian Johnstone

Carole Jones

Billy Kay

James Kelman (non-member)

Mark Leggatt

Joan Lennon

Joan Lingard

Robin Lloyd-Jones

Gerry Loose

Katrina Lovie

Mary MacDonald

Dr Margaret A Mackay

Ann E MacKinnon

Iseabail Macleod

Aonghas MacNeacail

Kona Macphee

Graeme Macrae Burnet

Susie Maguire

Robyn Marsack

Lynsey May

Ann Mcbain

Mary McCabe

Alexander McCall Smith

David McDonald

Anthony McGowan

Jane McKie

Mei-Ling McNamara

Linda Menzies

Greg Michaelson

Alison Miller

Hazel Morrison

Andrew Murray Scott

Maureen Myant

Helena Nelson

Liz Niven

Tom Pow

Chris Powici

Faith Pullin

Ian Rankin

Dr Mario Relich

Alan Riach

Lesley Riddoch

Fiona Rintoul

James Robertson

Frank Rodgers

Dilys Rose

Margaret Ryan

Chrys Salt MBE

Andrew Sclater

Sue Reid Sexton

Mary Smith

Dennis Smith

Claire Squires

Gerda Stevenson

Maureen Stewart

Chiew-Siah Tei

Don Toonen

Shelagh Toonen

Zoe Venditozzi

Harry D. Watson

Louise Welsh

Zoe Wicomb

Jennifer Williams

Les Wilson

Douglas Stuart Wilson

Fiona Wilson